By the way (just double posting it so it'll be obvious I've posted something new) I'm using the guide you made for Suikogaiden Vol 2. It's really helpful, so thanks for that, but I've noticed one little oversight. I'm referring to the following section:
It says that if you have 9 popularity, you'll get the Aisha scene in the infirmary. Well I just got there with 9 popularity and didn't get it. I reloaded a slightly earlier save and this time I made sure to hide in the closet in the scene prior to the infirmary. It's when hiding in there that you hear that Aisha has been taken to the infimary. If you choose the other option and quickly leave the room, you don't hear about that. Anyway, that time I did
get the Aisha scene. So it seems to be both the popularity and hiding in the closet are required (though to be as scientific as possible, I can't say for sure the popularity is
required, since both times I had 9 popularity. I know it would've been ages ago and you surely can't remember, but perhaps it's just that the one time you went in that room and chose the closet option, you happened to have 9 popularity.)
Anyway, not sure if you even care but I just thought I'd point it out if you wanted to edit the guide.