Well Ted had the soul eater and that didn't stop him from having a family with Teo and cia, so Tir and Kasumi could work out. Soul Eater could give us some romantic and dramatic scenes, the more he likes her, more he will want to leave her.Rune of Illusion wrote:Note too much at all. That is exactly why I'm against some characters coming back as they don't have too much to tell.
We do know that if Windy was still alive she would not be after Tir anymore because she cannot bear the Soul Eater Rune as she thought at first. Because of the Soul Eater rune's nature Tir would not get close to any other character besides Gremio so no the relationship between him and Kasumi will not work out. If they decide for him to remove the rune, it would be ripping off the Flame Champion from Suikoden 3.
Windy could search him out to make him her allied, by offering a dark deal, by making him her slave, etc... she did make Neclord her subordinate, she could do it to Tir too. Also there's the captain of Ghost ship, who was interested in the Soul Eater, maybe we could learn more about him.
I don't think bringing Tir back will necessarily burn his character, they could screw up, but they could make something cool. I don't think we should limit creativity, if we have a good idea, we should use it. It doesn't matter if the character had a grand role in other games.